Abstract
Collective action initiatives (CAIs) are increasingly promoted as mechanisms for enhancing women empowerment and fostering inclusive agricultural development among smallholder households. However, evidence remains inconclusive because most existing studies conceptualise CAIs as homogeneous entities, overlooking how differences in organisational orientation shape women’s multidimensional empowerment. This study addresses this gap by comparing the effects of business‐oriented collective action initiatives (BCAIs) and community‐oriented collective action initiatives (CCAIs) on women empowerment among smallholder households in Central Kenya. A mixed‐methods approach was employed using cross‐sectional data from 532 households and 10 focus group discussions (FGDs). Women’s empowerment was assessed among women only using the Women’s Empowerment in Agriculture Index (WEAI), which measures achievements across five domains: production, resources, income, leadership, and time. Compared with non‐participants, women participating in both BCAIs and CCAIs achieved significantly higher overall empowerment scores, as measured by the composite five domains of empowerment (5DE) index including the production, resources, income, leadership and time domains. However, the pathways differed. BCAIs primarily strengthened women’s income decision‐making and access to credit through greater market participation but reduced their production autonomy, asset ownership and leadership. In contrast, CCAIs generated broader improvements in production decision‐making, autonomy, asset ownership, credit access, leadership and public speaking through more inclusive governance and stronger social capital. Despite these gains, both CAI typologies increased women’s workloads and reduced leisure time due to unequal household labour allocation, while entrenched gender norms further constrained women’s control over productive assets and household income. The findings highlight that women empowerment depends not only on economic opportunities but also on organisational objectives, governance and prevailing gender relations. The findings underscore the need for gender‐responsive policies that support complementary business‐ and community‐oriented CAIs. This would enhance women’s economic opportunities, leadership, decision‐making, control over productive resources and equitable intra‐household gender relations, thereby fostering more transformative and sustainable empowerment outcomes.
How to cite
Catherine Nyambune Maindi, Hezron Nyarindo Isaboke (2026). Collective Action for Women Empowerment: Navigating Synergies and Trade‐Offs for Sustainable Outcomes Among Smallholder Households in Central Kenya. Advances in Agriculture. https://doi.org/10.1155/aia/6167801
Republished on Discussion Research from the global Crossref scholarly index with full credit to the original authors and Wiley. Licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
