Mathematics in mathematics education
Jill Adler · 2017
Abstract
What role does mathematics play in the teaching and research of some or all of the 'disciplines' of mathematics education, science education and the social sciences?This question was that to which I was asked to respond at the Academy of Science of South Africa's workshop on the mathematical sciences, held in September 2016.As suggested by the title, my focus here is on mathematics education, which is my field of expertise.An underlying interest or concern of participants in the workshop was what was offered in undergraduate mathematics at university, and how this did (or did not) support the ever-widening role mathematics is playing across disciplines.In addition, there were questions about the place and nature of undergraduate mathematics in the preparation for numerous diverse careers.The workshop took place over 2 days, and mine was the last of five presentations, following that of mathematics in the earth and biological sciences, economical sciences, engineering and physical sciences, and the mathematical sciences itself.Each presentation was followed by discussion in smaller groups and then plenaries in which the different groups shared key points of discussion.Each of the first four presentations is also the focus of a separate Invited Commentary in this issue.Together they provide a wealth of insight into developments in research in engineering, biology, economics and mathematics, and the implications of these for an undergraduate curriculum in the mathematical sciences.I was struck during the workshop discussions that the career of a mathematics teacher did not explicitly enter the landscape of possible careers emerging from studying mathematical sciences at university.Yet there was considerable attention to the limitations of the mathematical knowledge and mathematical ways of thinking of firstyear students across these fields and, by implication, the quality of mathematics teaching in our secondary schools.Teaching and research in mathematics teacher education was, appropriately, the planned focus of my talk.I opened my presentation with two critical questions that needed to be considered in the workshop:
